Skip to content
Use HAPPYDOGS10 & Get Extra 10% OFF For 6 DaysShop now!
Wish Lists Cart
0 items

PetBuds Blog

Prong Collar vs. No-Pull Dog Harness: Which one is better?

27 Nov 2024
Prong Collar vs. No-Pull Dog Harness Which one is better

When training dogs and controlling their behavior while walking, several tools are used, most commonly prong collars and no-pull dog harnesses. If you're thinking about a prong collar, there are several things you should know about it, its safety, and the alternatives. A prong collar is sometimes addressed as a ‘Pinch’ collar. Some believe that prong collars cause pain and distress while others believe that there is no better training tool than this. In this blog, we will be discussing everything about them and guide you in making a better decision for your pet.

What Is a Prong Collar? Are They Really Worth the Risk?

A prong collar is a kind of training tool that is used to train the dog or control the dog as they take a walk. It is used along with a chain that bears prongs that rest at the neck of the dog, and when the dog leash pulls, the prongs start pinching the skin and which is meant to correct bad behavior, such as pulling and lunging.

What is a no pull dog harness?

An alternative to a collar is a no-pull dog harness. This one discourages pulling by putting even pressure across the dog's chest and shoulders rather than concentrating it at the neck. There are additional comfort and control features like a perfect-fit dog harness or a dog harness with a handle. They come in various sizes and styles to fit your dog perfectly.

Adjustable No Pull Padded Dog Harness with Free 5ft Leash

Are Prong Collars Safe for Dogs?

Prong collars are actually more dangerous than they can be helpful. Even though some trainers argue that they provide fast corrections, they are known to cause physical injuries, such as bruising and cuts, and even injuries to the trachea. They also psychologically disturb dogs and make them anxious or fearful.

Will a Prong Collar Stop Pulling?

Prong collars may deter pulling temporarily, as they cause pain. Yet, this is not a permanent solution. Dogs usually become desensitized or get accustomed to the pain, continuing to pull.

Why Prong Collars Are Harmful to Dogs

The only positive thing about prong collars is that they make the training process easy for you. Apart from this, all you will find is its drawbacks, which are mentioned below:

  • Physical Injuries
  • The prongs may lead to abrasions, irritations, and long-term damage to the dog's neck and throat.

  • Psychological Impact
  • The pain may make dogs fearful or aggressive, which may affect their confidence in you.

  • Reinforcing Wrong Habits
  • Prong collars do not teach a dog to walk correctly but may stress and confuse the animal.

    Are Prong Collars Banned in Europe?

    Yes. Many European countries, such as Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, have banned prong collars because of animal welfare. These bans show a growing recognition of the need for humane training practices.

    What Can I Use Instead of a Prong Collar?

    If you want to discourage pulling without causing harm, you need to consider using the best dog harness. Harnesses, such as the best dog pulling harness or dog harness with handle, give control and comfort. You can pair it with a smart leash for dogs to train your dog gently and effectively.

    No-Pull Dog Harness vs. Prong Collar: Which one is better?

    Dog Harness vs Dog Collar

    Here is a comparison of prong collars with a no-pull dog harnesses. After looking at this comparison, it is not going to be difficult for you to choose one between the two.

    Evaluation No-Pull Dog Harness Prong Collar 
    Comfort

    This is comfortable and secure.

    It causes discomfort and pain.

    Safety Pressure is evenly distributed; thus, there is a reduced risk of causing harm.  It increases risk of neck and trachea injury.
    Training Effectiveness It encourages positive behavior without fear.   Temporary corrections are given but do not teach the dog long-term behavior.
    Fit Is adjustable to get the perfect fit.  Should be set with much care not to pinch the skin too much.
    Suitability Suitable for all sizes and breeds.  Unsuitable for small or sensitive breeds.

     

    Conclusion

    The right tool for your dog is essential to ensure comfort, safety, and training success. Although prong collars appear effective, the risks far outweigh the benefits. A safer and more humane alternative is a dog harness, such as the best dog harness or one with a handle. PetBuds, a UK-based online store, has all high quality dog harnesses and leashes to ensure the enjoyment you will have on a walk both by you and your beloved pet. Shop today and step closer toward more humane and intelligent training methods.

    Prev Post
    Next Post

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Q1. Is a prong collar harmful to dogs?
    Yes, a prong collar can be harmful to dogs because it can cause bruises or injuries on the neck of the dog as well as give psychological stress that causes the dogs to become anxious or fearful.
    Q2. What does a prong collar do?
    Q2. What does a prong collar do?
    Q3. Will a prong collar stop pulling?
    A prong collar can stop pulling because it is uncomfortable. However, it does not teach dogs to walk calmly and often creates other behavioral problems.
    Q4. What can I use instead of a prong collar?
    You can use a no-pull dog harness in place of a prong collar. It discourages gently pulling and keeps your dog safe and comfortable during walks.
    Q5. Are prong collars positive punishment?
    Yes, prong collars are a type of positive punishment in training. The effect is to add some discomfort to stop unwanted actions.

    Thanks for subscribing!

    This email has been registered!

    Shop the look

    Choose Options

    PetBuds
    Sign Up for exclusive updates, new arrivals & insider only discounts
    Edit Option
    Back In Stock Notification
    Compare
    Product SKURatingDescription Collection Availability Product Type Other Details
    this is just a warning
    Login
    Shopping Cart
    0 items